import TsmLean.Compile.Compile import TsmLean.Core.Semantics namespace TsmLean.Compile open TsmLean.Core /-! # Compiler-correctness theorem. `Source.Eval e v ⟹ TSM.MultiStep (start of compile e) (end of compile e, with v on stack)` The CompCert-flavored bridge: source-level evaluation and target-level execution agree on the value produced. -/ /-! ## Multi-step utilities. -/ theorem MultiStep.trans {s₁ s₂ s₃ : State} (h₁ : MultiStep s₁ s₂) (h₂ : MultiStep s₂ s₃) : MultiStep s₁ s₃ := by induction h₁ with | refl => exact h₂ | cons hs _ ih => exact .cons hs (ih h₂) theorem MultiStep.single {s s' : State} (h : step s = some s') : MultiStep s s' := .cons h (.refl _) /-! ## Single-step reduction lemmas. -/ theorem step_push {code : Code} {pc : Nat} {stack : List Value} {n : Int} (h_pc : pc < code.size) (h_get : code[pc]'h_pc = .push n) : step { code := code, pc := pc, stack := stack } = some { code := code, pc := pc + 1, stack := .vInt n :: stack } := by unfold step; rw [dif_pos h_pc, h_get] theorem step_pushB {code : Code} {pc : Nat} {stack : List Value} {b : Bool} (h_pc : pc < code.size) (h_get : code[pc]'h_pc = .pushB b) : step { code := code, pc := pc, stack := stack } = some { code := code, pc := pc + 1, stack := .vBool b :: stack } := by unfold step; rw [dif_pos h_pc, h_get] theorem step_add {code : Code} {pc : Nat} {a b : Int} {rest : List Value} (h_pc : pc < code.size) (h_get : code[pc]'h_pc = .add) : step { code := code, pc := pc, stack := .vInt b :: .vInt a :: rest } = some { code := code, pc := pc + 1, stack := .vInt (a + b) :: rest } := by unfold step; rw [dif_pos h_pc, h_get] theorem step_sub {code : Code} {pc : Nat} {a b : Int} {rest : List Value} (h_pc : pc < code.size) (h_get : code[pc]'h_pc = .sub) : step { code := code, pc := pc, stack := .vInt b :: .vInt a :: rest } = some { code := code, pc := pc + 1, stack := .vInt (a - b) :: rest } := by unfold step; rw [dif_pos h_pc, h_get] theorem step_mul {code : Code} {pc : Nat} {a b : Int} {rest : List Value} (h_pc : pc < code.size) (h_get : code[pc]'h_pc = .mul) : step { code := code, pc := pc, stack := .vInt b :: .vInt a :: rest } = some { code := code, pc := pc + 1, stack := .vInt (a * b) :: rest } := by unfold step; rw [dif_pos h_pc, h_get] theorem step_jmp {code : Code} {pc k : Nat} {stack : List Value} (h_pc : pc < code.size) (h_get : code[pc]'h_pc = .jmp k) : step { code := code, pc := pc, stack := stack } = some { code := code, pc := k, stack := stack } := by unfold step; rw [dif_pos h_pc, h_get] theorem step_jmpFalse_true {code : Code} {pc k : Nat} {rest : List Value} (h_pc : pc < code.size) (h_get : code[pc]'h_pc = .jmpFalse k) : step { code := code, pc := pc, stack := .vBool true :: rest } = some { code := code, pc := pc + 1, stack := rest } := by unfold step; rw [dif_pos h_pc, h_get] theorem step_jmpFalse_false {code : Code} {pc k : Nat} {rest : List Value} (h_pc : pc < code.size) (h_get : code[pc]'h_pc = .jmpFalse k) : step { code := code, pc := pc, stack := .vBool false :: rest } = some { code := code, pc := k, stack := rest } := by unfold step; rw [dif_pos h_pc, h_get] /-! ## Generic array-lookup helpers. -/ /-- The instruction at the boundary of a `c1 ++ c2 ++ #[op]` arrangement. -/ theorem getElem_at_op_boundary (c1 c2 : Code) (op : Instr) (h : c1.size + c2.size < (c1 ++ c2 ++ #[op]).size) : (c1 ++ c2 ++ #[op])[c1.size + c2.size]'h = op := by show ((c1 ++ c2) ++ #[op])[c1.size + c2.size]'h = op have hle : (c1 ++ c2).size ≤ c1.size + c2.size := Nat.le_of_eq Array.size_append rw [Array.getElem_append_right hle] simp [Array.size_append, Nat.sub_self] /-- Lookup at offset `pre.size + i` within a `pre ++ X ++ suf` array reduces to lookup at `i` within `X` itself, when `i < X.size`. -/ theorem getElem_at_offset (pre X suf : Code) (i : Nat) (h_lt : i < X.size) (h_pc : pre.size + i < (pre ++ X ++ suf).size) : (pre ++ X ++ suf)[pre.size + i]'h_pc = X[i]'h_lt := by have h_pre_X : pre.size + i < (pre ++ X).size := by rw [Array.size_append]; omega rw [Array.getElem_append_left h_pre_X] rw [Array.getElem_append_right (Nat.le_add_right _ _)] congr 1; omega /-! ## Per-construct compile-output lookup lemmas. -/ theorem compile_add_get_op (offset : Nat) (e1 e2 : Source.Expr) (h : (compile offset e1).size + (compile (offset + (compile offset e1).size) e2).size < (compile offset (Source.Expr.add e1 e2)).size) : (compile offset (Source.Expr.add e1 e2))[(compile offset e1).size + (compile (offset + (compile offset e1).size) e2).size]'h = .add := getElem_at_op_boundary (compile offset e1) (compile (offset + (compile offset e1).size) e2) _ h theorem compile_sub_get_op (offset : Nat) (e1 e2 : Source.Expr) (h : (compile offset e1).size + (compile (offset + (compile offset e1).size) e2).size < (compile offset (Source.Expr.sub e1 e2)).size) : (compile offset (Source.Expr.sub e1 e2))[(compile offset e1).size + (compile (offset + (compile offset e1).size) e2).size]'h = .sub := getElem_at_op_boundary (compile offset e1) (compile (offset + (compile offset e1).size) e2) _ h theorem compile_mul_get_op (offset : Nat) (e1 e2 : Source.Expr) (h : (compile offset e1).size + (compile (offset + (compile offset e1).size) e2).size < (compile offset (Source.Expr.mul e1 e2)).size) : (compile offset (Source.Expr.mul e1 e2))[(compile offset e1).size + (compile (offset + (compile offset e1).size) e2).size]'h = .mul := getElem_at_op_boundary (compile offset e1) (compile (offset + (compile offset e1).size) e2) _ h /-! ## Main theorem. The compile is offset-aware: `compile pre.size e` produces bytecode correctly placed at position `pre.size` in `pre ++ ... ++ suf`. -/ theorem compile_correct {e : Source.Expr} {v : Source.Value} (h_eval : Source.Eval e v) : ∀ (pre suf : Code) (rest : List Value), MultiStep { code := pre ++ compile pre.size e ++ suf, pc := pre.size, stack := rest } { code := pre ++ compile pre.size e ++ suf, pc := pre.size + (compile pre.size e).size, stack := v :: rest } := by induction h_eval with | intLit n => intros pre suf rest apply MultiStep.single have h_pc : pre.size < (pre ++ compile pre.size (Source.Expr.intLit n) ++ suf).size := by simp only [compile, Array.size_append, Array.size_singleton]; omega have h_get : (pre ++ compile pre.size (Source.Expr.intLit n) ++ suf)[pre.size]'h_pc = .push n := by have h_pre_ce : pre.size < (pre ++ compile pre.size (Source.Expr.intLit n)).size := by simp only [compile, Array.size_append, Array.size_singleton]; omega rw [Array.getElem_append_left h_pre_ce] rw [Array.getElem_append_right (Nat.le_refl _)] simp [compile, Nat.sub_self] have step_thm := step_push h_pc h_get (stack := rest) have h_size : (compile pre.size (Source.Expr.intLit n)).size = 1 := by simp [compile] rw [h_size] exact step_thm | boolLit b => intros pre suf rest apply MultiStep.single have h_pc : pre.size < (pre ++ compile pre.size (Source.Expr.boolLit b) ++ suf).size := by simp only [compile, Array.size_append, Array.size_singleton]; omega have h_get : (pre ++ compile pre.size (Source.Expr.boolLit b) ++ suf)[pre.size]'h_pc = .pushB b := by have h_pre_ce : pre.size < (pre ++ compile pre.size (Source.Expr.boolLit b)).size := by simp only [compile, Array.size_append, Array.size_singleton]; omega rw [Array.getElem_append_left h_pre_ce] rw [Array.getElem_append_right (Nat.le_refl _)] simp [compile, Nat.sub_self] have step_thm := step_pushB h_pc h_get (stack := rest) have h_size : (compile pre.size (Source.Expr.boolLit b)).size = 1 := by simp [compile] rw [h_size] exact step_thm | @add e1 e2 a b _ _ ih1 ih2 => intros pre suf rest have stepA := ih1 pre (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2 ++ #[.add] ++ suf) rest have stepB := ih2 (pre ++ compile pre.size e1) (#[.add] ++ suf) (.vInt a :: rest) have h_pre_e1_size : (pre ++ compile pre.size e1).size = pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size := by simp [Array.size_append] have h_code_A : pre ++ compile pre.size e1 ++ (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2 ++ #[Instr.add] ++ suf) = pre ++ compile pre.size (Source.Expr.add e1 e2) ++ suf := by simp only [compile, Array.append_assoc] have h_code_B : pre ++ compile pre.size e1 ++ compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2 ++ (#[Instr.add] ++ suf) = pre ++ compile pre.size (Source.Expr.add e1 e2) ++ suf := by simp only [compile, Array.append_assoc] rw [h_code_A] at stepA rw [h_pre_e1_size] at stepB rw [h_code_B] at stepB apply MultiStep.trans stepA apply MultiStep.trans stepB apply MultiStep.single have h_total_size : (compile pre.size (Source.Expr.add e1 e2)).size = (compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size + 1 := by show (compile pre.size e1 ++ compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2 ++ #[Instr.add]).size = (compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size + 1 simp [Array.size_append]; omega have h_in_comp : (compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size < (compile pre.size (Source.Expr.add e1 e2)).size := by simp [compile, Array.size_append] have h_full_pc : pre.size + ((compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size) < (pre ++ compile pre.size (Source.Expr.add e1 e2) ++ suf).size := by simp only [Array.size_append, h_total_size]; omega have h_op_get : (pre ++ compile pre.size (Source.Expr.add e1 e2) ++ suf)[pre.size + ((compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size)]'h_full_pc = .add := by rw [getElem_at_offset pre (compile pre.size (Source.Expr.add e1 e2)) suf ((compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size) h_in_comp h_full_pc] exact compile_add_get_op pre.size e1 e2 h_in_comp have h_step := step_add (a := a) (b := b) (rest := rest) h_full_pc h_op_get have h_pre_pc : pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size = pre.size + ((compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size) := by omega have h_post_pc : pre.size + ((compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size) + 1 = pre.size + (compile pre.size (Source.Expr.add e1 e2)).size := by rw [h_total_size]; omega rw [h_pre_pc, ← h_post_pc] exact h_step | @sub e1 e2 a b _ _ ih1 ih2 => intros pre suf rest have stepA := ih1 pre (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2 ++ #[.sub] ++ suf) rest have stepB := ih2 (pre ++ compile pre.size e1) (#[.sub] ++ suf) (.vInt a :: rest) have h_pre_e1_size : (pre ++ compile pre.size e1).size = pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size := by simp [Array.size_append] have h_code_A : pre ++ compile pre.size e1 ++ (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2 ++ #[Instr.sub] ++ suf) = pre ++ compile pre.size (Source.Expr.sub e1 e2) ++ suf := by simp only [compile, Array.append_assoc] have h_code_B : pre ++ compile pre.size e1 ++ compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2 ++ (#[Instr.sub] ++ suf) = pre ++ compile pre.size (Source.Expr.sub e1 e2) ++ suf := by simp only [compile, Array.append_assoc] rw [h_code_A] at stepA rw [h_pre_e1_size] at stepB rw [h_code_B] at stepB apply MultiStep.trans stepA apply MultiStep.trans stepB apply MultiStep.single have h_total_size : (compile pre.size (Source.Expr.sub e1 e2)).size = (compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size + 1 := by show (compile pre.size e1 ++ compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2 ++ #[Instr.sub]).size = (compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size + 1 simp [Array.size_append]; omega have h_in_comp : (compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size < (compile pre.size (Source.Expr.sub e1 e2)).size := by simp [compile, Array.size_append] have h_full_pc : pre.size + ((compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size) < (pre ++ compile pre.size (Source.Expr.sub e1 e2) ++ suf).size := by simp only [Array.size_append, h_total_size]; omega have h_op_get : (pre ++ compile pre.size (Source.Expr.sub e1 e2) ++ suf)[pre.size + ((compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size)]'h_full_pc = .sub := by rw [getElem_at_offset pre (compile pre.size (Source.Expr.sub e1 e2)) suf ((compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size) h_in_comp h_full_pc] exact compile_sub_get_op pre.size e1 e2 h_in_comp have h_step := step_sub (a := a) (b := b) (rest := rest) h_full_pc h_op_get have h_pre_pc : pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size = pre.size + ((compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size) := by omega have h_post_pc : pre.size + ((compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size) + 1 = pre.size + (compile pre.size (Source.Expr.sub e1 e2)).size := by rw [h_total_size]; omega rw [h_pre_pc, ← h_post_pc] exact h_step | @mul e1 e2 a b _ _ ih1 ih2 => intros pre suf rest have stepA := ih1 pre (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2 ++ #[.mul] ++ suf) rest have stepB := ih2 (pre ++ compile pre.size e1) (#[.mul] ++ suf) (.vInt a :: rest) have h_pre_e1_size : (pre ++ compile pre.size e1).size = pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size := by simp [Array.size_append] have h_code_A : pre ++ compile pre.size e1 ++ (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2 ++ #[Instr.mul] ++ suf) = pre ++ compile pre.size (Source.Expr.mul e1 e2) ++ suf := by simp only [compile, Array.append_assoc] have h_code_B : pre ++ compile pre.size e1 ++ compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2 ++ (#[Instr.mul] ++ suf) = pre ++ compile pre.size (Source.Expr.mul e1 e2) ++ suf := by simp only [compile, Array.append_assoc] rw [h_code_A] at stepA rw [h_pre_e1_size] at stepB rw [h_code_B] at stepB apply MultiStep.trans stepA apply MultiStep.trans stepB apply MultiStep.single have h_total_size : (compile pre.size (Source.Expr.mul e1 e2)).size = (compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size + 1 := by show (compile pre.size e1 ++ compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2 ++ #[Instr.mul]).size = (compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size + 1 simp [Array.size_append]; omega have h_in_comp : (compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size < (compile pre.size (Source.Expr.mul e1 e2)).size := by simp [compile, Array.size_append] have h_full_pc : pre.size + ((compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size) < (pre ++ compile pre.size (Source.Expr.mul e1 e2) ++ suf).size := by simp only [Array.size_append, h_total_size]; omega have h_op_get : (pre ++ compile pre.size (Source.Expr.mul e1 e2) ++ suf)[pre.size + ((compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size)]'h_full_pc = .mul := by rw [getElem_at_offset pre (compile pre.size (Source.Expr.mul e1 e2)) suf ((compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size) h_in_comp h_full_pc] exact compile_mul_get_op pre.size e1 e2 h_in_comp have h_step := step_mul (a := a) (b := b) (rest := rest) h_full_pc h_op_get have h_pre_pc : pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size = pre.size + ((compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size) := by omega have h_post_pc : pre.size + ((compile pre.size e1).size + (compile (pre.size + (compile pre.size e1).size) e2).size) + 1 = pre.size + (compile pre.size (Source.Expr.mul e1 e2)).size := by rw [h_total_size]; omega rw [h_pre_pc, ← h_post_pc] exact h_step end TsmLean.Compile