tests(tests/playground/expr_const_folding): another example for the paper

@kha I implemented a more complex example for the paper. The difference
in performance is awesome. On my Linux desktop:

Lean time:  3.34  secs
OCaml time: 11.72 secs

I believe that the difference in performance is due to destructive
updates happening in transformation functions such as `reassoc` and
`const_folding`. I will add a flag to Lean to disable `reuse/reset`
automatic insertion.

BTW, this test requires `ulimit -s unlimited` to avoid stack overflows.
This commit is contained in:
Leonardo de Moura 2019-02-15 12:03:58 -08:00
parent 06f1a2b1a0
commit eef60279e4
2 changed files with 145 additions and 0 deletions

View file

@ -0,0 +1,73 @@
inductive Expr
| Var : nat → Expr
| Val : nat → Expr
| Add : Expr → Expr → Expr
| Mul : Expr → Expr → Expr
open Expr nat
def mk_expr : nat → nat → Expr
| 0 v := if v = 0 then Var 1 else Val v
| (n+1) v := Add (mk_expr n (v+1)) (mk_expr n (v-1))
def append_add : Expr → Expr → Expr
| (Add e₁ e₂) e₃ := Add e₁ (append_add e₂ e₃)
| e₁ e₂ := Add e₁ e₂
def append_mul : Expr → Expr → Expr
| (Mul e₁ e₂) e₃ := Mul e₁ (append_mul e₁ e₂)
| e₁ e₂ := Mul e₁ e₂
def reassoc : Expr → Expr
| (Add e₁ e₂) :=
let e₁' := reassoc e₁ in
let e₂' := reassoc e₂ in
append_add e₁' e₂'
| (Mul e₁ e₂) :=
let e₁' := reassoc e₁ in
let e₂' := reassoc e₂ in
append_mul e₁' e₂'
| e := e
def const_folding : Expr → Expr
| (Add e₁ e₂) :=
let e₁ := const_folding e₁ in
let e₂ := const_folding e₂ in
(match e₁, e₂ with
| Val a, Val b := Val (a+b)
| Val a, Add e (Val b) := Add (Val (a+b)) e
| Val a, Add (Val b) e := Add (Val (a+b)) e
| _, _ := Add e₁ e₂)
| (Mul e₁ e₂) :=
let e₁ := const_folding e₂ in
let e₁ := const_folding e₂ in
(match e₁, e₂ with
| Val a, Val b := Val (a*b)
| Val a, Mul e (Val b) := Mul (Val (a*b)) e
| Val a, Mul (Val b) e := Mul (Val (a*b)) e
| _, _ := Mul e₁ e₂)
| e := e
def size : Expr → nat
| (Add l r) := size l + size r + 1
| (Mul l r) := size l + size r + 1
| e := 1
def to_string_aux : Expr → string → string
| (Var v) r := r ++ "#" ++ to_string v
| (Val v) r := r ++ to_string v
| (Add e₁ e₂) r := (to_string_aux e₂ ((to_string_aux e₁ (r ++ "(")) ++ " + ")) ++ ")"
| (Mul e₁ e₂) r := (to_string_aux e₂ ((to_string_aux e₁ (r ++ "(")) ++ " * ")) ++ ")"
def eval : Expr → nat
| (Var x) := 0
| (Val v) := v
| (Add l r) := eval l + eval r
| (Mul l r) := eval l * eval r
def main : io uint32 :=
let e := (mk_expr 23 1) in
let v₁ := eval e in
let v₂ := eval (const_folding (reassoc e)) in
io.println' (to_string v₁ ++ " " ++ to_string v₂) *>
pure 0

View file

@ -0,0 +1,72 @@
type expr =
| Var of int
| Val of int
| Add of expr * expr
| Mul of expr * expr;;
let dec n =
if n == 0 then 0 else n - 1;;
let rec mk_expr n v =
if n == 0 then (if v == 0 then Var 1 else Val v)
else Add (mk_expr (n-1) (v+1), mk_expr (n-1) (dec v));;
let rec append_add e1 e2 =
match (e1, e2) with
| (Add (e1, e2), e3) -> Add (e1, append_add e2 e3)
| (e1, e2) -> Add (e1, e2);;
let rec append_mul e1 e2 =
match (e1, e2) with
| (Mul (e1, e2), e3) -> Mul (e1, append_mul e2 e3)
| (e1, e2) -> Mul (e1, e2);;
let rec reassoc e =
match e with
| Add (e1, e2) ->
let e1' = reassoc e1 in
let e2' = reassoc e2 in
append_add e1' e2'
| Mul (e1, e2) ->
let e1' = reassoc e1 in
let e2' = reassoc e2 in
append_mul e1' e2'
| e -> e;;
let rec const_folding e =
match e with
| Add (e1, e2) ->
let e1 = const_folding e1 in
let e2 = const_folding e2 in
(match (e1, e2) with
| (Val a, Val b) -> Val (a+b)
| (Val a, Add (e, Val b)) -> Add (Val (a+b), e)
| (Val a, Add (Val b, e)) -> Add (Val (a+b), e)
| _ -> Add (e1, e2))
| Mul (e1, e2) ->
let e1 = const_folding e1 in
let e2 = const_folding e2 in
(match (e1, e2) with
| (Val a, Val b) -> Val (a*b)
| (Val a, Mul (e, Val b)) -> Mul (Val (a*b), e)
| (Val a, Mul (Val b, e)) -> Mul (Val (a*b), e)
| _ -> Mul (e1, e2))
| e -> e;;
let rec size e =
match e with
| Add (e1, e2) -> size e1 + size e2 + 1
| Mul (e1, e2) -> size e1 + size e2 + 1
| e -> 1;;
let rec eeval e =
match e with
| Val n -> n
| Var x -> 0
| Add (e1, e2) -> eeval e1 + eeval e2
| Mul (e1, e2) -> eeval e1 * eeval e2;;
let e = (mk_expr 23 1) in
let v1 = eeval e in
let v2 = eeval (const_folding (reassoc e)) in
Printf.printf "%8d %8d\n" v1 v2;;