This PR adds `reprove N by T`, which effectively elaborates `example
type_of% N := by T`. It supports multiple identifiers. This is useful
for testing tactics.
🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.ai/code)
---------
Co-authored-by: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
This PR enables the new E-matching pattern inference heuristic for
`grind`, implemented in PR #10422.
**Important**: Users can still use the old pattern inference heuristic
by setting:
```lean
set_option backward.grind.inferPattern true
```
In PR #10422, we introduced the new modifier `@[grind!]` for enabling
the minimal indexable subexpression condition. This option can now also
be set in `grind` parameters. Example:
```lean
opaque f : Nat → Nat
opaque fInv : Nat → Nat
axiom fInv_f : fInv (f x) = x
/-- trace: [grind.ematch.pattern] fInv_f: [f #0] -/
#guard_msgs in
set_option trace.grind.ematch.pattern true in
example {x y} : f x = f y → x = y := by
/-
The modifier `!` instructs `grind` to use the minimal indexable subexpression
(i.e., `f x` in this case).
-/
grind [!fInv_f]
```
This PR refines and clarifies the `meta` phase distinction in the module
system.
* `meta import A` without `public` now has the clarified meaning of
"enable compile-time evaluation of declarations in or above `A` in the
current module, but not downstream". This is now checked statically by
enforcing that public meta defs, which therefore may be referenced from
outside, can only use public meta imports, and that global evaluating
attributes such as `@[term_parser]` can only be applied to public meta
defs.
* `meta def`s may no longer reference non-meta defs even when in the
same module. This clarifies the meta distinction as well as improves
locality of (new) error messages.
* parser references in `syntax` are now also properly tracked as meta
references.
* A `meta import` of an `import` now properly loads only the `.ir` of
the nested module for the purposes of execution instead of also making
its declarations available for general elaboration.
* `initialize` is now no longer being run on import under the module
system, which is now covered by `meta initialize`.
This PR ensures users can select the "minimal indexable subexpression"
condition in `grind` parameters. Example, they can now write `grind [!
-> thmName]`. `grind?` will include the `!` modifier whenever users had
used `@[grind!]`. This PR also fixes a missing case in the new pattern
inference procedure.
It also adjusts some `grind` annotations and tests in preparation for
setting the new pattern inference heuristic as the new default.
This PR changes the order of steps tried when proving equational
theorems for structural recursion. In order to avoid goals that `split`
cannot handle, avoid unfolding the LHS of the equation to `.brecOn` and
`.rec` until after the RHS has been split into its final cases.
Fixes: #10195
This PR lets the `split` tactic generalize discriminants that are not
free variables and proofs using `generalize`. If the only
non-fvar-discriminants are proofs, then this avoids the more elaborate
generalization strategy of `split`, which can fail with dependent
motives, thus mitigating issue #10424.
This PR implements the new E-matching pattern inference heuristic for
`grind`. It is not enabled yet. You can activate the new behavior using
`set_option backward.grind.inferPattern false`. Here is a summary of the
new behavior.
* `[grind =]`, `[grind =_]`, `[grind _=_]`, `[grind <-=]`: no changes;
we keep the current behavior.
* `[grind ->]`, `[grind <-]`, `[grind =>]`, `[grind <=]`: we stop using
the *minimal indexable subexpression* and instead use the first
indexable one.
* `[grind! <mod>]`: behaves like `[grind <mod>]` but uses the minimal
indexable subexpression restriction. We generate an error if the user
writes `[grind! =]`, `[grind! =_]`, `[grind! _=_]`, or `[grind! <-=]`,
since there is no pattern search in these cases.
* `[grind]`: it tries `=`, `=_`, `<-`, `->`, `<=`, `=>` with and without
the minimal indexable subexpression restriction. For the ones that work,
we generate a code action to encourage users to select the one they
prefer.
* `[grind!]`: it tries `<-`, `->`, `<=`, `=>` using the minimal
indexable subexpression restriction. For the ones that work, we generate
a code action to encourage users to select the one they prefer.
* `[grind? <mod>]`: where `<mod>` is one of the modifiers above, it
behaves like `[grind <mod>]` but also displays the pattern.
Example:
```lean
/--
info: Try these:
• [grind =] for pattern: [f (g #0)]
• [grind =_] for pattern: [r #0#0]
• [grind! ←] for pattern: [g #0]
-/
#guard_msgs in
@[grind] axiom fg₇ : f (g x) = r x x
```
This PR adds a normalizer for non-commutative semirings to `grind`.
Examples:
```lean
open Lean.Grind
variable (R : Type u) [Semiring R]
example (a b c : R) : a * (b + c) = a * c + a * b := by grind
example (a b : R) : (a + 2 * b)^2 = a^2 + 2 * a * b + 2 * b * a + 4 * b^2 := by grind
example (a b : R) : b^2 + (a + 2 * b)^2 = a^2 + 2 * a * b + b * (1+1) * a * 1 + 5 * b^2 := by grind
example (a b : R) : a^3 + a^2*b + a*b*a + b*a^2 + a*b^2 + b*a*b + b^2*a + b^3 = (a+b)^3 := by grind
```
This PR changes the automation in `deriving_LawfulEq_tactic_step` to use
`with_reducible` when asserting the shape of the goal using `change`, so
that we do not accidentally unfold `x == x'` calls here. Fixes#10416.
This PR adds the ability to do `deriving ReflBEq, LawfulBEq`. Both
classes have to listed in the `deriving` clause. For `ReflBEq`, a simple
`simp`-based proof is used. For `LawfulBEq`, a dedicated,
syntax-directed tactic is used that should work for derived `BEq`
instances. This is meant to work with `deriving BEq` (but you can try to
use it on hand-rolled `@[methods_specs] instance : BEq…` instances).
Does not support mutual or nested inductives.
This PR fixes a bug where definitions with nested proofs that contain
`sorry` might not report "warning: declaration uses 'sorry'" if the
proof has the same type as another nested proof from a previous
declaration. The bug only affected log messages; `#print axioms` would
still correctly report uses of `sorryAx`.
The fix is that now the abstract nested proofs procedure does not
consult the aux lemma cache if the proof contains a `sorry`.
Closes#10196
This PR gives anonymous constructor notation (`⟨x,y⟩`) an error recovery
mechanism where if there are not enough arguments then synthetic sorries
are inserted for the missing arguments and an error is logged, rather
than outright failing.
Closes#9591.
This PR adds the `reduceBEq` and `reduceOrd` simprocs. They rewrite
occurrences of `_ == _` resp. `Ord.compare _ _` if both arguments are
constructors and the corresponding instance has been marked with
`@[method_specs]` (introduced in #10302), which now by default is the
case for derived instances.
This PR introduces the `@[specs]` attribute. It can be applied to
(certain) type class instances and define “specification theorems” for
the class’ operations, by taking the equational theorems of the
implementation function mentioned in the type class instance and
rephrasing them in terms of the overloaded operations. Fixes#5295.
Example:
```
inductive L α where
| nil : L α
| cons : α → L α → L α
def L.beqImpl [BEq α] : L α → L α → Bool
| nil, nil => true
| cons x xs, cons y ys => x == y && L.beqImpl xs ys
| _, _ => false
@[method_specs] instance [BEq α] : BEq (L α) := ⟨L.beqImpl⟩
/--
info: theorem instBEqL.beq_spec_2.{u_1} : ∀ {α : Type u_1} [inst : BEq α] (x_2 : α) (xs : L α) (y : α) (ys : L α),
(L.cons x_2 xs == L.cons y ys) = (x_2 == y && xs == ys)
-/
#guard_msgs(pass trace, all) in
#print sig instBEqL.beq_spec_2
```
It also introduces the `method_specs_norm` simpset to allow registering
further normalization of the theorems. The intended use of this is to
rewrite, say, `Append.append` to the `HAppend.hAppend` (i.e. `++`) that
the user wants to see. Library annotations to follow in a separate PR.
This PR makes the builtin Verso docstring elaborators bootstrap
correctly, adds the ability to postpone checks (which is necessary for
resolving forward references and bootstrapping issues), and fixes a
minor parser bug.
This PR implements sanity checks in the `grind ring` module to ensure
the instances synthesized by type class resolution are definitionally
equal to the corresponding ones in the `grind` core classes. The
definitional equality test is performed with reduction restricted to
reducible definitions and instances.
This PR fixes an issue where the "eta feature" in the app elaborator,
which is invoked when positional arguments are skipped due to named
arguments, results in variables that can be captured by those named
arguments. Now the temporary local variables that implement this feature
get fresh names. The names used for the closed lambda expression still
use the original parameter names.
Closes#6373
This PR enables using `notation` items in
`infix`/`infixl`/`infixr`/`prefix`/`postfix`. The motivation for this is
to enable being able to use `pp.unicode`-aware parsers. A followup PR
can combine core parsers as such:
```lean
infixr:30 unicode(" ∨ ", " \\/ ") => Or
```
Continuation of #10373.
This PR modifies pretty printing of `fun` binders, suppressing the safe
shadowing feature among the binders in the same `fun`. For example,
rather than pretty printing as `fun x x => 0`, we now see `fun x x_1 =>
0`. The calculation is done per `fun`, so for example `fun x => id fun x
=> 0` pretty prints as-is, taking advantage of safe shadowing.
The motivation for this change is that many users have reported that
safe shadowing within the same `fun` is confusing.
This PR adds support for non-commutative ring normalization in `grind`.
The new normalizer also accounts for the `IsCharP` type class. Examples:
```lean
open Lean Grind
variable (R : Type u) [Ring R]
example (a b : R) : (a + 2 * b)^2 = a^2 + 2 * a * b + 2 * b * a + 4 * b^2 := by grind
example (a b : R) : (a + 2 * b)^2 = a^2 + 2 * a * b + -b * (-4) * a - 2*b*a + 4 * b^2 := by grind
variable [IsCharP R 4]
example (a b : R) : (a - b)^2 = a^2 - a * b - b * 5 * a + b^2 := by grind
example (a b : R) : (a - b)^2 = 13*a^2 - a * b - b * 5 * a + b*3*b*3 := by grind
```
This PR adds the options `pp.piBinderNames` and
`pp.piBinderNames.hygienic`. Enabling `pp.piBinderNames` causes
non-dependent pi binder names to be pretty printed, rather than be
omitted. When `pp.piBinderNames.hygienic` is false (the default) then
only non-hygienic such biner names are pretty printed. Setting `pp.all`
enables `pp.piBinderNames` if it is not otherwise explicitly set.
Implementation note: this is exposing the secret pretty printer option
`pp.piBinderNames` that was being used within the signature pretty
printer.
Closes#1134.
This PR fixes a few bugs in the `rw` tactic: it could "steal" goals
because they appear in the type of the rewrite, it did not do an occurs
check, and new proof goals would not be synthetic opaque. This PR also
lets the `rfl` tactic assign synthetic opaque metavariables so that it
is equivalent to `exact rfl`.
Implementation note: filtering old vs new is not sufficient. This PR
partially addresses the bug where the rw tactic creates natural
metavariables for each of the goals; now new proof goals are synthetic
opaque.
Metaprogramming API: Instead of `Lean.MVarId.rewrite` prefer
`Lean.Elab.Tactic.elabRewrite` for elaborating rewrite theorems and
applying rewrites to expressions.
Closes#10172
This PR adds a `pp.unicode` option and a `unicode("→", "->")` syntax
description alias for the lower-level `unicodeSymbol "→" "->"` parser.
The syntax is added to the `notation` command as well. When `pp.unicode`
is true (the default) then the first form is used when pretty printing,
and otherwise the second ASCII form is used. A variant, `unicode("→",
"->", preserveForPP)` causes the `->` form to be preferred; delaborators
can insert `→` directly into the syntax, which will be pretty printed
as-is; this allows notations like `fun` to use custom options such as
`pp.unicode.fun` to opt into the unicode form when pretty printing.
Additionally:
- Adds more documentation for the `symbol` and `nonReservedSymbol`
parser descriptions.
- Adds documentation for the
`infix`/`infixr`/`infixl`/`prefix`/`postfix` commands.
- The parenthesizers for symbols are improved to backtrack if the atom
doesn't match.
- Fixes a bug where `&"..."` symbols aren't validated.
This is partial progress for issue #1056. What remains is enabling
`unicode(...)` for mixfix commands and then making use of it for core
notation.
This PR uses the per-constructor `noConfusion` principles (from #10315)
in the `mkNoConfusion` app builder, if possible. This means they are
used by `injection`, `grind`, `simp` and other places. This brings
notable performance improvements when dealing with inductives with a
large number of constructors.
This PR adds `T.ctor.noConfusion` declarations, which are
specializations of `T.noConfusion` to equalities between `T.ctor`. The
point is to avoid reducing the `T.noConfusionType` construction every
time we use `injection` or a similar tactic.
```lean
Vec.cons.noConfusion.{u_1, u} {α : Type u} (P : Sort u_1) {n : Nat}
(x : α) (xs : Vec α n) (x' : α) (xs' : Vec α n)
(h : Vec.cons x xs = Vec.cons x' xs')
(k : n = n → x = x' → xs ≍ xs' → P) : P
```
The constructions are not as powerful as `T.noConfusion` when the
indices of the inductive type are not just constructor parameters (or
constructor applications of these parameters), so the full
`T.noConfusion` construction is still needed as a fallback.
It may seem costly to generate these eagerly, but given that we eagerly
generate injectivity theorems already, and we will use them there, it
seems reasonable for now.
To further reduce the cost, we only generate them for constructors with
fields (for others, the `T.noConfusion` theorem doesn't provide any
information), and we use `macro_inline` to prevent the compiler from
creating code for these, given that the compiler has special support for
`T.noConfusion` that we want it to use).
An earlier version of this PR also removed trivial equations and
un-HEq-ed others, leading to
```
(k : x = x' → xs = xs' → P)
```
in the example above. I backed out of that change, as it makes it harder
for tactics like `injectivity` to know how often to `intro`, so better
to keep things uniform.
This PR adds range support to`BitVec` and the `UInt*` types. This means
that it is now possible to write, for example, `for i in (1 : UInt8)...5
do`, in order to loop over the values 1, 2, 3 and 4 of type `UInt8`.
This PR adds the type `Std.Internal.Parsec.Error`, which contains the
constructors `.eof` (useful for checking if parsing failed due to not
having enough input and then retrying when more input arrives that is
useful in the HTTP server) and `.other`, which describes other errors.
It also adds documentation to many functions, along with some new
functions to the `ByteArray` Parsec, such as `peekWhen?`, `octDigit`,
`takeWhile`, `takeUntil`, `skipWhile`, and `skipUntil`.
This PR reimplements `mkNoConfusionType` in lean, thus removing the
remaining C code related to this construction.
Also uses the ctor elimination principles only when there are more than
three ctors.
This PR implements a new E-matching pattern inference procedure that is
faithful to the behavior documented in the reference manual regarding
minimal indexable subexpressions. The old inference procedure was
failing to enforce this condition. For example, the manual documents
`[grind ->]` as follows
`[@grind →]` selects a multi-pattern from the hypotheses of the theorem.
In other words, `grind` will use the theorem for forwards reasoning.
To generate a pattern, it traverses the hypotheses of the theorem from
left to right. Each time it encounters a **minimal indexable
subexpression** which covers an argument which was not previously
covered, it adds that subexpression as a pattern, until all arguments
have been covered.
That said, the new procedure is currently disabled, and the following
option must be used to enable it.
```
set_option backward.grind.inferPattern false
```
Users can inspect differences between the old a new procedures using the
option
```
set_option backward.grind.checkInferPatternDiscrepancy true
```
Example:
```lean
/--
warning: found discrepancy between old and new `grind` pattern inference procedures, old:
[@List.length #2 (@toList _ #1#0)]
new:
[@toList #2#1#0]
use `set_option backward.grind.inferPattern true` to force old procedure
-/
#guard_msgs in
set_option backward.grind.checkInferPatternDiscrepancy true in
@[grind] theorem Vector.length_toList' (xs : Vector α n) : xs.toList.length = n := by sorry
```
This PR moves the definitions and basic facts about `Function.Injective`
and `Function.Surjective` up from Mathlib. We can do a better job of
arguing via injectivity in `grind` if these are available.
This PR shares common functionality relate to equalities between same
constructors, and when these are type-correct. In particular it uses the
more complete logic from `mkInjectivityThm` also in other places, such
as `CasesOnSameCtor` and the deriving code for `BEq`, `DecidableEq`,
`Ord`, for more consistency and better error messages.
This PR upstreams the Verso parser and adds preliminary support for
Verso in docstrings. This will allow the compiler to check examples and
cross-references in documentation.
After a `stage0` update, a follow-up PR will add the appropriate
attributes that allow the feature to be used. The parser tests from
Verso also remain to be upstreamed, and user-facing documentation will
be added once the feature has been used on more internals.
This PR implements model-based theory combination for types `A` which
implement the `ToInt` interface. Examples:
```lean
example {C : Type} (h : Fin 4 → C) (x : Fin 4)
: 3 ≤ x → x ≤ 3 → h x = h (-1) := by
grind
example {C : Type} (h : UInt8 → C) (x y z w : UInt8)
: y + 1 + w ≤ x + w → x + w ≤ z → z ≤ y + w + 1 → h (x + w) = h (y + w + 1) := by
grind
example {C : Type} (h : Fin 8 → C) (x y w r : Fin 8)
: y + 1 + w ≤ r → r ≤ y + w + x → x = 1 → h r = h (y + w + 1) := by
grind
```
This PR removes `grind →` annotations that fire too often, unhelpfully.
It would be nice for `grind` to instantiate these lemmas, but only if
they already see `xs ++ ys` and `#[]` in the same equivalence class, not
just as soon as it sees `xs ++ ys`.
In the meantime, let's see what is using these.
