inductive LE : Nat → Nat → Prop | refl : LE n n | succ : LE n m → LE n m.succ theorem LE.trans : LE m n → LE n o → LE m o := by intro h1 h2 induction h2 with | refl => assumption | succ h2 ih => exact succ (ih h1) theorem LE.trans' : LE m n → LE n o → LE m o | h1, refl => h1 | h1, succ h2 => succ (trans' h1 h2) -- the structural recursion in being performed on the implicit `Nat` parameter inductive Even : Nat → Prop | zero : Even 0 | ss : Even n → Even n.succ.succ theorem Even.add : Even n → Even m → Even (n+m) := by intro h1 h2 induction h2 with | zero => exact h1 | ss h2 ih => exact ss ih theorem Even.add' : Even n → Even m → Even (n+m) | h1, zero => h1 | h1, ss h2 => ss (add' h1 h2) -- the structural recursion in being performed on the implicit `Nat` parameter theorem mul_left_comm (n m o : Nat) : n * (m * o) = m * (n * o) := by rw [← Nat.mul_assoc, Nat.mul_comm n m, Nat.mul_assoc] inductive Power2 : Nat → Prop | base : Power2 1 | ind : Power2 n → Power2 (2*n) -- Note that index here is not a constructor theorem Power2.mul : Power2 n → Power2 m → Power2 (n*m) := by intro h1 h2 induction h2 with | base => simp_all | ind h2 ih => exact mul_left_comm .. ▸ ind ih /- The following example fails because the structural recursion cannot be performed on the `Nat`s and the `brecOn` construction doesn't work for inductive predicates -/ -- theorem Power2.mul' : Power2 n → Power2 m → Power2 (n*m) -- | h1, base => by simp_all -- | h1, ind h2 => mul_left_comm .. ▸ ind (mul' h1 h2)